LEGAL (PROACTIVE) Q&A: What are the steps I can take to reduce the likelihood of getting sued over the accessibility of my ICT?
This article was developed as part of
The Accessibility Switchboard Project
from the
National Federation of the Blind Jernigan Institute
January 2017, Version 1.0.1
Creative Commons License: CC BY-SA 4.0
Brief answer
What are the steps I can take to reduce the likelihood of getting sued over the accessibility of my Information and Communication Technology (ICT)?
- Decide you want to make your ICT accessible.
- Make your ICT accessible.
- Publicly announce your accomplishments and continued commitment.
Note:
- Doing #1 immediately reduces the likelihood.
- Not doing #2 significantly increases the likelihood.
- Omitting #1 and #2, and only doing #3 is a recipe for getting sued.
In-Depth Answer: What are the steps I can take to reduce the likelihood of getting sued over the accessibility of my ICT?
There have been a number of lawsuits against and a number of structured settlements with businesses that have demonstrated unwillingness to tackle the accessibility of their Information and Communication Technology (ICT). You may yourself have some apprehension if you consider that you might be vulnerable to a lawsuit.
If you have ICT that has known accessibility problems, or if you have never thought of accessibility issues before, know that there are solutions that are readily available. This is why we created the Accessibility Switchboard project, to provide short introductory articles on topics relevant to industry, and links to further in-depth resources for the specialists working for and with you. These articles cover what is needed to work towards having a successful approach to ICT accessibility in your organization.
Sure, there will be work to be done, because magic wands are in short supply. However, the amount of effort and investment of time and resources is probably way less than you anticipate. Ready to roll up your sleeves?
1. Decide you want to make your ICT accessible
- Why would I want to address accessibility in my organization? (read this first)
- Does accessibility have to be expensive?
- Introducing organization-wide accessibility approaches: a guide to making a successful pitch
2. Make your ICT accessible
- What procedures should I use to test my ICT for accessibility? (read this first)
- How do I ensure my products work for people with disabilities?
- Where do I get good / accurate information on ICT (web, software, mobile, electronic document) accessibility?
- A roadmap for organizational accessibility for large ICT vendors
- An introductory guide for small businesses and startups
- I’ve been told to make sure the things I procure are accessible. How do I do this?
- How do I find a knowledgeable consultant?
- How can I provide an accessible work environment?
- I have a job applicant who has notified me they have a disability. What should I do now?
- Beyond offering employees a complaint process: proactive measures to tackle accessibility issues
3. Publicly announce your accomplishments and continued commitment
- How to provide an accessible work environment? (read this first)
- I have a job applicant who has notified me they have a disability. What should I do now?
- Beyond offering employees a complaint process: proactive measures to tackle accessibility issues
What if you do only parts of these suggestions?
Doing #1 immediately reduces the likelihood
We link (above) to a guide on how you can make a successful pitch to executives to gain their commitment to work on accessibility in your organization. Executives are the only ones who can make this kind of commitment, so if you don’t have that, you are increasing the likelihood of being sued.
People with disabilities are really looking for equitable access to ICT, using solutions that are readily available. We also wrote guides for people with disabilities on how to articulate their needs to companies, and how to approach change makers. In the guidance, we suggest that legal action should be the very last resort. Without obtaining an organization-wide commitment to accessibility from the highest levels, the first resort suggestion given in the guidance (consumers should contact customer support) will be a frustrating experience at best, or an exercise in futility at worst.
Not doing #2 significantly increases the likelihood
You can only sue someone who is suspected of breaking the law. The laws are there for a reason. The laws only require companies to do what is technically and practically possible.
Other companies have made achievements in ICT accessibility that can be cited as benchmarks.
Omitting #1 and #2, and only doing #3 is a recipe for getting sued
Lady Justice is typically depicted with a blindfold, and we instinctively know that justice should be ‘blind’. This is ‘blind’ in terms of fairness. Up to 20% of the population has some kind of disability, and the legal system has been set up to provide a measure of fairness to all people in society.
A commitment to providing accessible ICT can also be supported by committing to making an accessible work environment, hiring and promoting people with disabilities, and being proactive in terms of employee engagement with accessibility issues.
Whether loud marketing proclamations or subtle footnote statements on your web page, the proof is in the pudding. If you market your products based on quality, and you don’t have a quality assurance process, you’re likely to lose customers. If you’re a big multinational company and you have a statement that says you respect diversity, but you have a boardroom comprising only white, able-bodied, straight men, how will people believe that you actually ‘respect diversity’?
Publicly announcing you are accessible, without making a genuine effort to make your ICT accessible, and without obtaining executive support for your accessibility program efforts, is a pudding that people with disabilities are going to find unappetizing to say the least.
Reducing risk does not eliminate risk
You could do #1, #2, and #3, and still get sued. However much you try to reduce any given risk you cannot eliminate it completely. But, if you’ve lowered your risk by being proactive on accessibility efforts then you’ll be in a much better negotiating position if you do happen to get sued.
About this article
Authors
This article is published as part of The Accessibility Switchboard Project, an initiative of the National Federation of the Blind Jernigan Institute with support from the members of the Accessibility Switchboard Project Community Of Practice, and from the Maryland Department of Disabilities.
Suggested citation
The Accessibility Switchboard Project. LEGAL (PROACTIVE) Q&A: What are the steps I can take to reduce the likelihood of getting sued over the accessibility of my ICT?. January 2017, Version 1.0.1 National Federation of the Blind Jernigan Institute. Available: http://switchboard.nfb.org/
Feedback, additions and updates
The authors welcome feedback on this and other articles in the Accessibility Switchboard. Use the feedback form to provide updates, new case studies, and links to new and emerging resources in this area. The feedback form can also be used to join the mailing list for notification of new content and updates from the Accessibility Switchboard.
Copyright, use and reproduction
Accessibility Switchboard articles are published under the Creative Commons License Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International. You are free to share (copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format), and to adapt (remix, transform, and build upon the material) for any purpose, even commercially. This is under the following terms: (1) Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use; (2) ShareAlike — If you remix, transform, or build upon the material, you must distribute your contributions under the same license as the original. For more detail on the license, see CC BY-SA 4.0 on the Creative Commons website.
Picture credits
‘The Justice, in front of the Supreme Court of Brazil’. by Morio. CC BY-SA 3.0. Cropped from original.